Legal Insights

Cop Didn’t Know the Law. Turn Signal Not Required. 4th Amendment Says the Evidence Is THROWN OUT.

An Indiana cop pulled a driver over for no turn signal, found a gun and drugs, and lost ALL of it in court. Why? The law never required him to signal. Here is how one illegal traffic stop turned into a 4th Amendment win at the Indiana Supreme Court.

In Lanier v. State (Ind. Nov. 10, 2026), an Indianapolis officer stopped Parnell Lanier for turning right out of a Phillips 66 parking lot without signaling. During the stop, police found a handgun, marijuana, a digital scale, and suspected cocaine. But Indiana repealed its old 200-foot turn signal rule in 2023. The statute left in its place only requires a signal for turns made while on a highway and for lane changes. Pulling out of a private parking lot is neither.

The State argued the officer made a “reasonable mistake of law” under Heien v. North Carolina, the 2014 U.S. Supreme Court case that lets some police mistakes slide. The Indiana Supreme Court said no. When the law is clear, the officer is expected to know it. The stop violated the Fourth Amendment, and every piece of evidence was suppressed.

Should police get a pass when they misread the law, or should they have to know what they enforce? Tell me in the comments.

Case: Lanier v. State, No. 26S-CR-405 (Ind. Nov. 10, 2026), on transfer from No. 25A-CR-769.

Read the court’s opinion (PDF)

Case discussed:

  • Heien v. North Carolina, 574 U.S. 54 (2014)

More traffic stop cases: can 20 seconds of questioning unlawfully extend a traffic stop? and Flock license plate camera searches violate the Fourth Amendment. See all the opinions behind our videos in our Court Opinions library.

If police pulled you over for something that is not actually against the law and then searched your car, the evidence can be challenged. See our illegal search and seizure page.

This video is for education and entertainment, not legal advice.

Filed under: 4th Amendment & Searches

Anton Vialtsin

Anton Vialtsin, Esq., E.I. is a San Diego criminal defense attorney and CJA Panel member in the Southern and Central Districts of California. New case breakdowns every Wednesday on YouTube.

📞 Call 619-357-6677